one curve, three lenses, and the discipline of never letting a number float free of the business it describes.
Akshay Muralidharanco-founder & CEO · with Noel James co-anchoring
the bridge
week 2, you read a balance sheet. now: what the numbers decide.
the enrichment floor gave you the statements. this week the statements start making decisions: who to hire, where to put money, and whose money to take.
the corporate life cycle
the curve everything sits on
akshay's rule for the week: no concept floats. every term must sit somewhere on this curve, and most terms change their answer depending on where you stand.
you are here
stage 1 · startup
everything is a hypothesis
Rapido, the early years
Beyond Snack
Wakefit
who do you hiregeneralistspeople who do five jobs badly enough to find the one that matters
where do you investfinding the productevery rupee buys learning, not scale
equity or debtequity, onlydebt needs something to lend against. there is nothing yet
you are here
stage 2 · growth
the machine works. feed it.
Lenskart
Nykaa
Zerodha
who do you hirespecialiststhe five-job generalist becomes five hires
where do you investdistributionthe product is proven; reach is the bottleneck
equity or debtmostly equity, first debtgrowth is still risky, but there is finally something to secure
you are here
stage 3 · maturity
the machine runs. tune it.
Asian Paints
TCS
Maruti
who do you hireoperatorspeople who make a running machine 2% better every year
where do you investefficiencycapacity, cost, moats. adventures go through committee
equity or debtdebt, gladlypredictable cash makes borrowing cheap. lenders queue up
you are here
stage 4 · decline
the market moved. now what?
Vodafone Idea
BSNL
MTNL
who do you hireturnaround handscutters, restructurers, and the rare reinventor
where do you investsurvival cashevery rupee defends the core or funds the pivot
equity or debtnobody's moneylenders see no future cash. equity fled earlier
the three lenses, formalised
same questions. answers flip by stage.
startup
growth
maturity
decline
hire
generalists
specialists
operators
turnaround
invest
learning
distribution
efficiency
survival
money
equity only
equity, first debt
debt, gladly
nobody's
lab · the curve
vodafone idea and lenskart walk into your office
three decisions for each company: a key hire, an investment call, a financing choice. same three questions, two very different spots on the curve.
the point you should be able to say out loud by 15:15: your answers flip because the stage changed, not the logic.
day 2 · tuesday
does it make money on one?
bites everywhere
contribution margin
the anatomy of one chai
teaching estimates, directionally right
bites here
customer acquisition cost
what swiggy spent to get you
the first-order discount, the free delivery, the ads that followed you for a week: add it up and your first biryani cost them several hundred rupees. that bill has a name, CAC, and a question attached: what are you worth to them over the years?
hold that question. it has a name too, and it's next.
bites here
lifetime value & payback
the barber's first-haircut discount
half price on your first cut loses him money that day. but a customer who stays comes back every month for years. the discount is CAC; the years of cuts are LTV; and the number of visits until he's made the discount back is the payback period.
the whole subscription economy is this barber, at scale.
bites here
break-even
the 200-plate wedding order
the tent, the cooks, the transport are fixed: paid whether 50 plates serve or 500. each plate's ingredients are variable. somewhere in that 200-plate order is the plate where the fixed costs are finally eaten, and every plate after it is the caterer's actual profit.
quote a wedding without knowing which plate that is, and you're gambling, not catering.
the pivot
₹100 next year is not ₹100 today.
bites everywhere
time value of money
the FD proof
₹100 in a fixed deposit at 7% becomes ₹107 next year. so ₹107 arriving next year is worth exactly ₹100 today. that 7% is a discount rate: the FD, running backwards. every discount rate is just this, with more risk in it.
bites everywhere
net present value
the second-outlet decision
₹11.2L of today-money coming in, against ₹10L going out: NPV is positive, the outlet clears. teaching estimates, directionally right.
bites everywhere
internal rate of return
the same decision, as a rate
IRR is the discount rate at which that NPV hits exactly zero. if the project's IRR beats the rate you demand, it clears the bar. NPV answers in rupees, IRR answers in percent: two views of one question.
tomorrow's question, then: where does the bar itself come from?
day 3 · wednesday
every project must clear a bar. what is the bar?
bites everywhere
capital budgeting
choosing between real investments
a new outlet, a new machine, a new market: rank every candidate's NPV against the bar, fund what clears it, starve what doesn't. the discipline is identical at every stage of the curve. only the stakes change: a startup bets the company, a mature firm bets a percentage.
bites here
the two prices of money
why equity is the expensive money
debtcontracted, often secured, first in line to be paid. lower risk to the lender, so it charges less: think low double digits in india, before tax breaks make it cheaper still.
equitylast in line, promised nothing, paid only if the business wins. that risk demands winnings: equity holders expect returns well above what any lender charges.
teaching estimates, directionally right
bites everywhere
WACC
the blend is the bar
take a monday maturity company: four-fifths funded by equity expecting say 14%, one-fifth by debt costing say 7% after tax. blend by weight and the company's money costs roughly 12.5%. that number is the bar from yesterday: any project earning less than the money funding it destroys value while looking busy.
teaching estimates, directionally right
bites here
debt capacity · lab callback
why vodafone idea can't borrow, and asian paints won't need to
lenders lend against predictable future cash. decline has none it can promise, so no one lends to Vi at a price Vi can survive. maturity has plenty, which is the irony of credit: debt is cheapest for exactly the companies that need it least.
afternoon · new lens
how the money that funds you thinks.
bites here
fund mechanics
one fund, one decade, one pipeline
when a VC pushes you on timelines, this pipeline is why: your exit has to land inside their fund's life, not just inside your dreams.
bites everywhere
the macro tie · week 3 callback
the fed and the repo decide how much dry powder exists
cheap money fills LP pockets and LP pockets fill funds: that was 2021. rates rise, the chain runs backwards, and the funding winter you traced in week 3 arrives. the pipeline on the last slide is plumbed straight into the weather.
the signpost
this is the basics. term 4 goes deep.
enough, for now, to hold your own in singapore: in october you sit across plug and play's partners and portfolio founders, and this vocabulary is your entry ticket.
day 4 · thursday
two honest ways to value anything.
bites everywhere
discounted cash flow
future cash, dragged to today, summed
yesterday's discounting, industrialised: forecast the cash, discount each year at the bar, add it up. the answer is a value, and every input is an argument.
bites here
terminal value
where most of the number hides
that dashed box, everything after year five, routinely carries the majority of a DCF's value. which means most of the valuation rests on the years you can see least. that should worry you every single time, in your own models most of all.
bites everywhere
relative valuation
what would someone actually pay?
the shortcut the market runs on: price = earnings times what buyers currently pay per rupee of earnings for similar firms. PE and its cousins skip the forecast entirely and ask the neighbours instead.
the honesty slide
both methods lie. differently.
DCF lies whenthe growth assumptions are dreams. the machinery is rigorous; the inputs are yours. garbage in, precision out.
multiples lie whenthe comparables are in a bubble. you're not valuing the company, you're importing the market's mood.
run both. where they disagree is where the real conversation lives.
lab · the big valuation cases
four companies, two methods each, one half-day
teams take one company each and build the valuation both ways: a DCF you can defend line by line, and a multiples view honest about its comparables. all figures on the next slide are teaching estimates, directionally right; your job is the reasoning, not the decimal.
ready to meet them?
the cases
press to meet them
case 1 · the listed burnerswiggyrevenue in the ₹15,000cr range, losses narrowing, listed in 2024 and priced daily by a moody market. your DCF vs the ticker: who's wrong? (yes, the CAC from tuesday is in here.)
case 2 · the multiple that movedhonasa · mamaearthD2C at ₹2,000cr-scale revenue, thin profits, listed at a rich multiple that has since compressed hard. were the comparables ever comparable?
case 3 · the 2021 price tagboAt₹3,000cr-scale revenue, roughly breakeven, last priced above a billion dollars in the cheap-money window. does that price survive the funding winter you traced in week 3?
case 4 · the unpriced giantzohobootstrapped, deeply profitable, and never priced by any market. no down rounds, no ticker, no anchor. what is it worth, and who gets to say?
teaching estimates, directionally right · figures for reasoning practice, not reporting
press → to reveal
day close
tomorrow, no teaching. bring your business.
friday · the clinic
your mission business, three lenses, mentors in the room
bring your numbers, whatever state they're in. every business gets the same treatment: where does it sit on the curve, does it make money on one, and what does its money cost? mentors circulate; nobody presents, everybody works.
mission 06 · the road ahead
presentations monday, september 7
between now and then, the clinic's three questions become your memo's spine. and the standard for the room:
a valuation you can't defend is just a wish with decimals.